
Telluride Regional Real Estate Market Analysis
The San Miguel County real estate market continues its solid upward trend
as 2005 has boasted markedly impressive figures for three straight quarters.
Within the first three quarters of the year, totals for dollar volumes
and sales numbers were already significantly ahead of the two highest
years on record, 2004 and 2000, putting the year-to-date figures at record-setting
levels. According to Judi Kiernan of Telluride Consulting, at the close
of the third quarter, year-to-date dollar volumes were at $533 million,
a 22% increase from the same time in 2004 ($439 million) and a 23% increase
from the same time period in 2000 ($434 million).
Year Dollar Volume Number of Sales
Jan.-Sept. 2005 $533.3 million 671 sales
Jan.-Sept. 2004 $438.5 million 639 sales
Jan.-Sept. 2003 $275.0 million 502 sales
Jan.-Sept. 2002 $247.5 million 507 sales
Jan.-Sept. 2001 $338.0 million 536 sales
Jan.-Sept. 2000 $434.2 million 734 sales
Year-to-date condominium sales are still soaring in both
Mountain Village and Telluride with $88 million in total dollar volume
for Mountain Village and $55 million for Telluride. These figures are
vastly ahead of 2004, which was deemed the “Year of the Condo.”
County vacant residential land was also incredibly strong thus far in
2005 with $66 million in total dollar volume, compared to $57 million
in the first three quarters of 2004. Additionally, single-family homes
continue to thrive with $88 million in total dollar volume for Mountain
Village and $37 million in total dollar volume for Telluride.
Jan. - Sept. 2005 Jan. - Sept. 2004 % Increase
Telluride Condo Sales $55 million $46 million 20%
Mountain Village Condo Sales $88 million $57 million 54%
The Telluride region has successfully persevered through the national
slump that followed September 11, 2001, one of the toughest economic slowdowns
of our time. The former precedent-setting year of 2000 is no longer the
revered record holder it once was, as 2004 has trumped its numbers dramatically.
In its entirety, 2004 was a banner year with regard to the San Miguel
County real estate market with total dollar volume, according to Judi
Kiernan of Telluride Consulting, at $617 million.
Year Dollar Volume Number of Sales
1998 $257 million 597
1999 $415 million 925
2000 $546 million 965
2001 $431 million 722
2002 $319 million 666
2003 $433 million 748
2004 $617 million 854
Telluride’s Existence Outside
the Real Estate Bubble
Real
estate and financial analysts, brokers, buyers and sellers across the
nation have expressed concern related to the real estate “bubble”
and its potential likelihood to burst. Regardless of what might occur
in other regions of the U.S., the Telluride regional marketplace is located
on an island outside that precarious bubble. As a destination resort with
limited zoning, this region is simply not subject to the many bubble-causing
factors found elsewhere across the country.
Fueling this concern is a drastic increase in supply nationwide
of residential homes. With such an oversupply, prices are likely to soften
with sellers competing for the same group of investors. The Telluride
regional marketplace is characterized by a very limited zoning of only
approximately 5,000 single-family equivalents. With 60% built out in a
county that is roughly 70% United States Forest Service land, the market
supply has always been outstripped by demand. Consequently, supply will
forever be limited, and appreciation will remain constant with only an
occasional leveling of price structure in the market during periods such
as the one that followed 9/11 and the ensuing recession.
Additionally, investments by second homeowners are based
on lifestyle, as well as the bottom line. Buyers seek the beauty of Telluride
and its way of life as a respite from an often hectic metropolitan existence.
Like Aspen, and other unique resort communities, Telluride exists in its
own market, one resistant to typical trends hitting mainstream market
areas. To underscore the uniqueness of the market related to limited supply,
there are only 100 homes total currently for sale in the region’s
two most significant marketplaces—the historic Town of Telluride
and Mountain Village.
The
volatility of the stock and financial markets and low interest rates have
driven investors to real estate in the recent past. There is considerable
concern by analysts that many of these investors are over-leveraged and
may desire to divest with a rise in rates and possible recession. This
may include “dumping” property in order to accumulate cash.
According to an article by business journalist Dana Blankenhorn, “Highly
leveraged buyers with adjustable interest mortgages above $500,000 will
find themselves with a payment and property taxes that are impossible
to make when interest rates rise…the biggest mistake is when the
market becomes flooded with sellers trying to dump their houses because
their payments have tripled…” Again, Telluride, as well as
places like Aspen and Vail, is not the norm. Most property owners are
not highly leveraged and therefore have significant equity and staying
power. They tend to have considerable financial strength and will simply
wait out a slow market before liquidating.
The Telluride market, like Aspen and other resort areas,
is not infallible. Slow-downs and a leveling of appreciation occur on
occasion, such as the recession of 2001-2002, but it is relatively safe
to assume that if the national market declines or the bubble bursts, Telluride
would likely experience a temporary leveling off, rather than a decline,
before regaining market strength. A case in point, increases of 36% and
42% in gross dollar sales were realized in 2003 and 2004, respectively,
following a two-year plateau, and 2005 YTD is promising to be a record
year with sales up 22% over a record 2004. Although little appreciation
occurred during 2001-2002, values held for patient sellers and significant
inflation occurred thereafter.
In summary, Telluride has for the past 35 years been a
very stable marketplace with limited negative outside economic influence.
Scarce inventory and a discriminating group of financially sound investors
in the second home market assure that this marketplace will not fall prey
to the real estate bubble.
Click here to receive a
market analysis for the type of property you are interested in. |
 |
|